Monday, February 22, 2016

Misunderstanding the (alleged) ‘Congo contraception’ case

by Dr. Edward Peters, Canon Lawyer, Professor at Sacred Heart Seminary, Advisor to the Vatican

Even by the standards of his reign, the presser Pope Francis conducted on his return flight from Mexico has provoked an unusual number of questions. I wish to address only one of those here.

Preliminarily, I note that the burden is not on the negative to prove that something did not occur, it is on the affirmative to prove that the alleged something did occur. That said, though, it now seems all but certain that the ‘permission’ or ‘approval’ which Francis has claimed his predecessor Pope Paul VI gave for Congo nuns facing rape to use contraception simply does not exist. See e.g. Fr. Zuhlsdorf or John Allen*.

Unfortunately this myth has been invoked by the pope as if it were a fact of Church history, and, more importantly, in a way that suggests it might be a precedent to be considered in deciding whether contraception may also be used to prevent pregnancy in some cases of possible birth defects. That claim would take Pope Francis’ contraception remarks into a very different area. No longer are we musing about a point of Church history (as interesting as that might be), now we are dealing with Church moral teaching. The stakes become dramatically higher.

For the whole article, click here.

See Phil Lawler’s Article “Pope Paul VI and the Nuns in the Congo: an Illusory Precedent” 

{ 2 comments }

“Catholics Come Home” Book now available

by Steve Ray on February 22, 2016

Catholics Come Home’s Tom Peterson has a special offer: Catholics Come Home Book Now $1.99! 

Today, for a limited time, you can purchase the Kindle eBook edition of my popular evangelization book, Catholics Come Home: God’s Extraordinary Plan for Your Life, for just $1.99! That’s more than 80% off the normal price!

 What if you don’t have a Kindle or e-reading device? Not a problem. You can still read the Catholics Come Home eBook on pretty much any computer, phone, or tablet.

 Just click here to download one of Amazon’s free Kindle reading apps, purchase the $1.99 eBook on Amazon, and you’re ready to read and evangelize with more passion and direction!

Your brother in Christ, Tom Peterson

{ 0 comments }